One fun-filled fall day quickly turns into a troublesome one for the LoSanto family. Eight-year-old Jake and six-year-old Todd deeply love and enjoy their gray green-eyed cat, Georgie (named for our first president). But Grandma thinks he's a big annoying pain. He disappoints her because she expects him to be a good cat, and he's often mischievous. Dad, Grandpa, and the boys think he's funny. While each family member deals differently with their cat's unusual behavior, Georgie's unexpected action on this day thrusts the family into a worrisome situation. Can this family pull together to solve the cat mystery? Will Georgie's unexpected action change Grandma's thoughts about him? As the mystery continues, does the family give up in their efforts to help Georgie? How would your family handle this situation?