Thirty-four-year-old meteorologist Sandford "Sand" Oliver of Radar, Pennsylvania, is having a problem finding a husband. To warm up Sand's dreary life, Kat Shaw, his best friend of forever, sets up brunch between Sand and the adorable, sexy, and famous pastry chef, Ben Cutter.
Ben is not in Sand's league, though. Not only has Ben written best-selling pastry cookbooks, but he just happens to have his own television baking show called Sugaring Ben.
During their brunch, the two men hit it off rather well and find each other attractive. After a few more dates and a business trip with Ben to Pittsburgh, Sand realizes the pastry chef is perfect, and definitely a possible candidate as husband material.
No one is perfect, though, including Ben Cutter. Somehow, in some way, the man is flawed. Sand doesn't know what the flaw is, but when he finds out, will his happy world with Ben crumble? Or will a teaspoon of sugar be enough to make their relationship work?