Chad Best, article writer for Artist Trade, is instructed by his editor to head to Haven Island in Lake Erie to interview the famous ashtray artist, Finn O'Rourke. A glassblower, Finn has the reputation of being a monster to the public, particularly the media, but Chad is fascinated by him and can't wait to meet the artist.
When Chad arrives on the island, he and Finn get things off to a bad start. But Chad soon learns there's a softer side to the artist, and Finn O'Rourke isn't the monster his super fans have made him out to be.
To Chad's surprise, Finn woos the writer and seduces him. Emotionally ensnared by the artist, Chad finds himself falling for Finn. When his visit comes to an end, will Chad choose to return to his busy life, or stay on the artist's island with a man he might love?